Domino's Pizza in Stillwater

1524 N Boomer Rd, Stillwater, OK 74075, United States

★★★★☆
(432 reviews)
Specialties: Pizza delivery Chicken wings restaurant Pizza restaurant Pizza takeaway

About

Looking for great pizza in Stillwater? Domino's is your go-to destination for delicious pizza and a wide range of mouthwatering menu options. Whether you're craving classic pepperoni pizza, cheesy pasta, stuffed cheesy bread, flavorful salads, or chicken wings, our Stillwater pizza location has got you covered. Enjoy the convenience of delivery, carryout, or curbside pickup with our exclusive Domino's Carside Delivery service. Wherever you are, we have an option for pizza near you. Explore our menu, discover local coupons, and track the status of your lunch, dinner, or late-night order at 1524 N Boomer Road.

Website
dominos.com
Address
1524 N Boomer Rd, Stillwater, OK 74075, United States
Plus Code
4WQM+4H Stillwater, Oklahoma, USA
Time Zone
America/Chicago

Business Hours

Monday
10:30 am–1 am
Tuesday
10:30 am–1 am
Wednesday
10:30 am–1 am
Thursday
10:30 am–1 am
Friday
10:30 am–2 am
Saturday
10:30 am–2 am
Sunday
10:30 am–1 am

Services

Service options
Kerbside pickup No-contact delivery Delivery On-site services Takeaway
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Payments
Debit cards Credit cards
Parking
Free of charge street parking Free parking lot

Reviews

3.9
★★★★☆
432 reviews

Most Mentioned

window (12) management (11) wings (7) drive through (6) sandwich (6) toppings (6) coupons (5) call (5) delivery driver (5) kids (5)
5 stars
239
4 stars
67
3 stars
27
2 stars
23
1 stars
76
March 15, 2025

Horrible service, Horrible Staff, Will never be ordering from here again and will be contacting corporate on this behalf. Waited over 2 hours on my food and after an hour they still hadn’t put in my order. The cashier demonstrated a lack of intelligence and didn’t even understand how to work the register properly. The cashier took like 30 minutes to take my order and kept on answering the phone and ignoring me when I asked about my order. Staff was messing up online orders and over heard the other complaints from different customer. Saw customer leave from how frustrated they were. Store operations was horrible. Staff was even dropping pans and dough on the floor like come on if you can handle running this store shut it down or hire someone that’s capable of meeting your customers needs.

March 12, 2025

I placed my order on the app. I was advised it would be 30-40 minutes before it was ready. We were 30 minutes away as it was and I even waited 15 minutes before we left the house. When I went in to pick up my order because the app showed it was ready, I was told it would roughly be another 20 minutes. We waited in line, and when I pulled to the drive up window, I was told they couldn't find my order. Someone offered an 2 orders of lava cakes, or something else for the inconvenience. I was feeling 6 people so 2 lava cakes wouldn't have worked so I asked if they would do 2 orders of the bread bites instead. I was told yes and the order would be out as soon as possible. I waited an additional 20 minutes for my order to be remade. 2 of the pizzas were wrong, They didn't have all of the drinks id ordered so they had to sub it for other stuff that was left, none of them had the garlic butter on the crust like they were ordered with AND even though they offered to give 2 orders for all of the mess up on there end I only got 1.... I understand it was a Saturday evening but this is beyond ridiculous!! I get you may be out of the drinks.... Cool they gave me something else...... But they lost my order, made it wrong when they remade it and promised me something as compensation and didn't provide what was promised. On top of the coat of it all! Management needs to get a hold of stuff up there! No telling how much money is walking out the door!

March 5, 2025

Only good thing about this place was the 9.99 deal that is now gone. Food is constantly undercooked even when you ask for well done, they skimp on toppings, and have rude employees. Go somewhere else for pizza lol.

March 4, 2025

I ordered a Large New York Style Meatzza extra cheese add mushrooms, green peppers, onion, and black olives. When my husband picked it up it was just a vegetable pizza no meat so they said they’d remake it. He called to let me know what happened and he literally had to step outside because the workers were inside playing, using profanity, and being loud to where I could barely hear him on the phone. They even say when another customer walks in, “we better settle down before they set how we really act in here but oh well” and laughed. My husband gets the pizza and brings it home and what do you know, NO extra cheese. I called to make them aware because after 2 opportunities, clearly all the playing and not paying attention is leading to wrong orders having to made over again. Being that I paid for extra cheese I either want it or the money back for the extra cheese. I called and I explain to the employee what happened and he remembers, I tell him they still forgot the extra cheese part and he recognizes that they did forget the extra cheese. He put his manager on the phone, Logan, and immediately Logan said I know the second pizza was made right I watched it. I told him it didn’t have the extra cheese on top that I paid for and he got an attitude and started being rude. I decided to end the call and take my loss but Domino’s app has been deleted from my phone and had completely lost my business.

March 2, 2025

Ordered 5 pizzas, waited an hour, still in prep. Called, guy that answered was a jerk, said it would be a while because they screwed up a bunch of orders. Told him that wasn't our problem, when asked for our food to be delivered in 30 minutes he said he was refunding our money. They couldn't even at least let the customers know that they're idiots

February 24, 2025

Overcharged and Terrible Customer Service! I ordered two pizzas from this Domino’s location, and the total should have been $21.84 (including tax). However, my card was charged $49.14! When I brought this issue to the staff and manager, they refused to help. The manager told me, “There’s nothing we can do,” and I had to call my bank myself. If your system overcharges customers, you should take responsibility and assist in resolving the issue, not push the problem onto the customer. This is completely unacceptable!

January 20, 2025

Last two times order took over 2 hours to arrive and was cold. This last time ordered a pizza and it arrived burnt and cold, so inedible, and part of the order was missing after taking over 2 hours to arrive. Ordered at 6:30, arrived at 8:45. Store said it would send new order of missing item but at this rate it will be 10pm before rest of food gets here. Weather was not great tonight but will never order from this location again.

January 18, 2025

Waited over an hour for our pizzas ( 4 single topping) when we got home there were old and one was folded inhalf. I called 3 times before someone answered and then was told that they were busy so there wasn't anything they were going to do about it and hung up on. I called back and asked to speak to a manager and was put on hold and then immediately hung up on again. Customer service is horrible.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 2, 2025

Pizza is always hot and fresh

March 26, 2025

Overpriced undercooked and undercut not worth it

March 26, 2025

They were really slow and messed up my order. Parking: The parking sucks Food : 2/5 |

★★★
March 19, 2025

I had ordered a large and got a medium, pizza was still good though so I cant complain too much

March 9, 2025

Placed my order at 9:20. They had thrown my order away when I went to pick it up at 9:55 because they were to close at 10. They were also very very rude.

March 9, 2025

Worst customer service for online orders.

March 9, 2025

horrible horrible this use to be my favorite dominos but recently just straight trash don t recommend

★★★★
Verified Reviewer
February 9, 2025

The food is good, the staff is awesome and they need more business but they dont deliver and they dont have a drive-thru

Verified Reviewer
February 9, 2025

My order was messed up. Horrible pizza night

February 9, 2025

My order was going to be delayed by over an hour, the delivery person delivered it to the wrong address, and an hour later, they left for delivery again but still didn t deliver the pizza. After more than 3 hours of waiting, I still haven t received any pizza.

★★★★
Verified Reviewer
January 9, 2025

As far as affordable take out pizza, we prefer dominos. Its fast, pretty consistent on the quality and taste. I like their crust and the sauce is good.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
December 9, 2024

Wonderful service and NY style Pizza BUT pizza not sliced all the way through so it was impossible to eat a piece in the car... Also, not much corn meal, if any, on the bottom

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
December 9, 2024

Dominos is consistent. You get what you order and the drive up window at this location is great!

November 9, 2024

Everything about this place is horrible, the management and everything, they don t wear gloves when making your food and the manger Dylan threatens every customer up in there!!! Complete disgust

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
October 9, 2024

Great service and good pizza.

October 9, 2024

I went in to pick up a pizza the other day and heard a man yelling in the back and a girl came around the corner crying. And im pretty sure I heard one of the girls call him by the name of Dylan(pretty sure he s the GM) Idk what was going on but it seemed very unprofessional and my pizza wasn t even that good.

★★
Verified Reviewer
October 9, 2024

I m out of town and my daughter suggested Doninos, and as a non-local, I had no other suggestions. I regularly have awesome pizza from local pizza joints where I m from in IL. I paid TWENT FREAKIN DOLLORS for a pizza that was far WORSE than a frozen Freschetta or Digiorno brand pizza. Crust is flavorless, cheese is generic, sauce taste isn t there, the only saving grace would be some seasoning, which is completely absent. You re not thinking above a teenager level when it comes to your pizza . How you re still in business is beyond me.

September 9, 2024

One pizza didnt have toppings over most pf it including sauce and cheese and toppings very dissatisfied!

September 9, 2024

I ordered a pizza and some bread things at this location, and paid a whopping $3 for sauces. Tell me why I didn t receive them? Oh and then I tried to call the store, and the dude said he put me on hold THEN HUNG UP ON ME. This establishment should be frowned upon and needs new employees. Shame on you dominos. Shame. On. You.

★★★★★
August 9, 2024

Managers Madi and Dylan were incredibly helpful after Uber eats was not. Thank you so much!

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
August 9, 2024

I think they put crack in the lava cakes because its so damn addicting.

★★★★★
August 9, 2024

I ordered wings the ocky way and they delivered <3

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
August 9, 2024

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust! Food

★★★★
August 9, 2024

This Dominoes is a good one. The pizza is always fresh and delicious. It is always made quickly as well. Great deal.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
August 9, 2024

It is what it is and thats what its supposed to be. Thank you Food

★★★★★
July 9, 2024

Havent ordered pizza delivery in a few years, my sons have moved back in and wanted pizza they were so fast and the food was hot and delicious! Thank you Stillwater Oklahoma Dominos

★★★★
Verified Reviewer
June 9, 2024

Great pizza and fast service

★★★★★
May 9, 2024

#LegalizeMarinara2024

April 9, 2024

Stillwater OK Dominos is ok Papa John s is way better!

★★
April 9, 2024

Pizza was over cooked

★★
April 9, 2024

This dominos needs to quit being so skimpy. Why does there seem like there is less dough than normal? Ever since covid the pies have been very thin, like theyre cutting back or something but still charging full price, if not more. The $6 delivery charge is absolutely ridiculous, it used to be like $3.75, I am not too sure why there is such a surge there as well. I wouldnt mind if the pizzas were High Quality but I feel like im paying premium prices for minimal services. Ive worked at a dominos before, I know for a fact there are specific measurements/weights for the portions of cheese and for 1-3+ toppings for each pizza size. Why does this dominos continually skimp out on all of these? Also, whoever is cutting the pies are consistently cutting them unevenly, I order regularly, please figure out what this is about, there is a chart clearly describing how the pizzas should be cut. And lastly someone forgot to put the powder on the lava cakes and include a utensil, Im not too sure why this simple act is being neglected, its powder and a spoon. Please do better Stillwater Dominos!

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

Excellent

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

I don t even like pizza very much but dominoes is my one exception

★★★★★
April 9, 2024

When i think about to order pizza. It is only from your guys!!! Thank you very much.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

I am not losing weight because of them

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

Got food, friendly workers, on time service that was quick . The driveway on boomer road is weird and backwards and hard for a big truck like mine to maneuver when one goes on backwards like o did lol

April 9, 2024

Food was burnt and dry and when I called they seemed they didnt wanna talk about an issue that was theyre fault. Im a regular and Im fixing to switch to pizza huts meal deal. This is ridiculous

★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

Ordered online and they didnt get our pizzas right. Didnt put green peppers in half or black olives on half and paid extra for those toppings

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

Absolutely awesome ..ty Dillon and ur staff your awesome

April 9, 2024

The all-around service was absolutely terrible. They were not familiar with the menu, they gave me the wrong address. Which left my order in the window under a light for 40 minutes after they come out of the oven I asked for a new order in which she replied I looked at him and they look okay. By the time I got them home they werent worth eating. Very disappointing experience.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

Hot fast and affordable with friendly service. Thank you

April 9, 2024

My husband and I have had a horrible flu and were sick of soup and decided to order some solid food and what we got was as disgusting as this flu!!! We ate one piece of the pizza and one piece of the stuffed bread last night and put the rest of it up for today. After the first bite I had a long black hair (I m blonde and so is my husband!!!) in my mouth!!! After examining the pizza we discovered another long black hair in the pizza (both were baked in NOT on top!!!! We immediately called and were told by the so called manager (Dillon) that since it was from yesterday s order that they couldn t refund it but would give us a credit!!! Are you kidding me, like we d ever order from them again!!! The manager was just plain rude about it!!! We travel all over the country and have ordered from Dominoes all over the country and have never had such a horrible and disgusting experience!!!! DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS LOCATION!!!! I WILL BE CONTACTING THE HEALTH DEPARTMENT FIRST THING IN THE MORNING!!!!

★★★★★
April 9, 2024

Out of all the fast food places that come to mind that I frequently get a smile and an enthusiastic enjoy your day, and there arent many, this Dominos is one of them. Great job, keep it up.

April 9, 2024

We dont get delivery often and normally have no issues but tonight both mine and my mans pizzas were burnt around the edges and none of the 3 pizzas were cut to where I could pick up the whole pizza. so I called them to get the ones that were burnt remade and they apparently have started requiring you to return the pizzas you get remade even if you have ate some of it. To me like thats nasty cause you dont know if someone is sick or not so why would you take them back.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

Note that you cannot order at the drive up window, but you can walk in, call, or order online.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

I always order online and go pick up at the pick window. I love the pick-up window as it makes it really easy to drive up, grab my food, and exit the premises. the staff is always friendly and helpful. I like to get a philly cheesesteak pizza on their thin crust. Its sooo good. If you havent tried it, I highly recommend it. They have plenty of option, not just pizza and I always love to do their 6.99ea for two or more items deal.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

The pizzas are kinda burnt and suck a lot lately

★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

Parking: Limited number of parking, but enough for a small town like Stillwater. Food

★★★★★
April 9, 2024

Good Food, Top Tier Service, iffy prices

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

I really liked their pizza but we ordered dr pepper and instead they gave us a cherry soda which we didnt like.

April 9, 2024

Ordered an hour ago, no order. Called the local store, and after being hung up on once already, told my order was just now in the oven. You def took my money quickly, but your online order time, not so much huh?

April 9, 2024

They have a driver who drives a white Nissan Sentra Texas plates RMM9793 that drives extremely aggressive. Almost rear ended me with my newborn and 2 yr old in the car. Then whipped around me and flipped me off. When I had my turn signal on way in advance. All while they had the dominos sign on top of their car. Give dominos a bad look. Dominos needs to make sure their drivers arent acting like a fool while on shift with their signs. I love dominos food but their drivers need to chill seriously because peoples lives are more important then you delivering the pizza as fast as you can smh. And flipping someone off while on shift is just wow. So unprofessional.

★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2024

whoever is making the signs out front deserves a raise

★★★★★
April 9, 2024

Love pizza great customer service

April 9, 2023

Dominos used be so convient for my partner and I. We could call in run to the store and pick up their $7.99 pick up special.Now besides picking it up for that price they make you order online which is not always convenient. If I could post with no stars I would

★★★★
April 9, 2023

Good pizza, wonderful employees. My only complaint is the extremely broken website I had to use to order.

★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Customer service was very good. Other than that you know what Dominos Pizza are like !

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Always very quick with getting orders ready, and pizzas are very consistent(ly good).

★★★★★
April 9, 2023

Very capable staff, good deals.

★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Pizzas have less toppings. Not enough sauces on either pizzas either They were supposed to give us $3.00 back on our order for picking up but they did not. The cheese dippers are good. They owe us $3.00 plus to try it again.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Pizza is great as is the wings an salads .

April 9, 2023

Got 2 pizzas today & parmesan bites. Took a bite out of my 3rd piece of pizza and tasted a cleaning solution. Something with bleach? Now my mouth feels numb. Im pregnant. If I loose my baby over this I will be contacting a lawyer.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Yummy and delicious pizza. I loved it.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Thank you guys for always have my pizza hot and fresh

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Awesome staff

★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

When they actually care about the quality of pizza theyre baking and decide to pop the dough bubbles rather than letting them explode and ruin the pizza and still serve them to customers, the product turns out decent. They rarely, if ever, make ingredient mistakes. Overall good experiences with this store - if theyd just learn how to pop the dough bubbles.

★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Rude, slow service. Great food though

★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Food was good. Unfortunately I did not get the 2 dips I ordered. I paid for 2 ranch dip sauces. Got no dip.

Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Such unfortunate changes that your Store now require for ordering is ridiculous. Some of us do not trust to order our pizza online over the risk of scammers. So, folks, write this new change down in your notes. DOMINOS NO LONGER ALLOWS YOU TO ORDER The Mix and Match deals through delivery service, over the phone. This store is only looking out for what is more convenient for themselves. This was the final straw for me. Farewell & good riddance, Dominos.

★★
April 9, 2023

Probably should be a 1 star due to customer service. Used the app to order. An hour and a half goes by and now their claiming their order tracker isn t accurate. Have been told twice it s out for delivery. Hope it s warm.

April 9, 2023

If I could I would give zero stars, dominos in Stillwater is the absolute worst! They were upset they had to remake my pizza so this is what I got, I will never order from here again!

April 9, 2023

Ordered two pizzas and a cheesy bread from the location at 81 and Lewis. Worse pizza we have ever had! Dry and burnt. Was totally disappointed!

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Very friendly staff. Fresh out the oven. Got a sandwich and it was fire

April 9, 2023

My daughter is 18 yrs old with mild disabilities and severe anxiety. She is trying to get outside of her comfort zone and try new things and doing more things for herself. This evening she had a friend stay and they had their own money so my daughter asked if she could make her own profile and order her own pizza. I sat down and helped her make a Dominos profile and showed her the menu and coupons. She put in her order and the total come to $49.75. Now my daughter cant count money very good and she only grabbed $50 not thinking about the tip. My daughter went to the door and took the food and paid ( the much older lady) and my husband was on the other side of the door( where the lady couldnt see him) getting some $ out of his wallet to give for a tip and the delivery driver looked at the money and said said what a whole measly .25 for the driver?. Well my daughter learned a valuable lesson this evening on When to tip and when not to tip. Needless to say she left with her measly .25 tip.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Great service, fast food!

April 9, 2023

Lost my order and finally delivered to the wrong address, they said they called but they never did.

★★★★★
April 9, 2023

dylans a phenomenal guy !

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Great service. Good food

★★★★★
April 9, 2023

DYLAN IS THE BEST DELIVERY DRIVER EVERRRRR!!!! (From the homies @ 004)

★★★
April 9, 2023

Food was decent. Quick delivery. My go too dinner when traveling and staying in a hotel.

April 9, 2023

This was the skimpiest Philly cheese steak pizza ever! Very disappointed for the price. Where s the beef? There s mushrooms but not much beef. Paid extra for extra large but they used less topping than even a large has. I ve eaten this very same style specialty pizza at Domino s in many locations for many years but this one from Stillwater, is, by far, the worst ever. Do better Stillwater Domino s.

Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Ordered my parents a pizza to their room and they received a cold pizza that seemed like it had been sitting for hours. Call the store the next morning and they are extremely rude to me and tell me I have to pay another delivery fee to have the food remade and brought back to them? Seriously dominos? I ll be contacting corporate.

★★★★★
April 9, 2023

Ordered here many times over the last few years and have rarely had any issues. They have it figured out at this location

Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Ordered my pizza at 5:13 in the afternoon it is now 747 I ve had to call four times and I still do not have a Pizza they have my money but I have no pizza worst experience of my life. do not order from this Domino s In Stillwater. I am 55 years old I ll be a lot of pizza in my life never have I been this disgusted with a pizza place. My husband talked to the GM and they couldn t even be civil then calling corporate.

★★★★★
April 9, 2023

Love it

★★★★★
April 9, 2023

I have lived in several cities and never have I gotten the service like I get here in Stillwater. The folks at this location take pride in their jobs and deliver the best dominoes pizza, I have ever gotten, every time!

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2023

Great drive through experience - hot and fresh with nice staff.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

Very good

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

Good food. Really enjoy the pasta bread bowl

★★
April 9, 2022

Ordered 6 pizzas and 3 cinnamon twists with extra icing, parmesean and peppers. Got message it was ready. Drive up window told me they messed it up and to pull forward and they would bring it out. 15 minutes later I went in and all my order was just sitting on the shelf while we were being ignored. Then they didn t include my icing and I had to add more cinnamon to an order because they barely put any on the twists. Not my best experience

★★
April 9, 2022

This has got to be the nastiest tasting gluten free pizza Ive had. The crust was hard. The flavor of the crust was that of a burnt piece of cardboard. The ingredients in the top were pepperoni onion and bell pepper. The toppings did not taste fresh. The value was not good either. It cost over $21 for a small gluten free crust 3 topping and an order of boneless wings. Not worth the price. Dont waste your money.

April 9, 2022

Took nearly three hours for them to deliver our pizza. They delivered to the wrong room the first time- that didn t even have a number on the door and clearly wasn t ours. Then waited another hour for them to show up again and almost deliver it to the wrong room again.

★★★★★
April 9, 2022

They were really busy, and did a great job!

★★★★★
April 9, 2022

My family has ordered from this dominos for a little over a year. They have great wings, sandwiches, pasta, and of course pizza.. Their salads are always fresh, the desserts are yummy too! The service has always been fast and friendly as well!

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

My experience with Dominos pizza is always amazing best pizza place i go to like they never get my order wrong there always so nice and fast they are my go to tbh

★★★★
April 9, 2022

Great ordering online experience

★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

3 stars due to little unhygienic conditions, no one was wearing gloves in the restaurant. They were making pizzas with bare hands. I was just assured due to high heat, all the germs and bacterias would get killed but company should follow proper hygiene.

★★★★★
April 9, 2022

I literally love these guys. I ve lived in Stillwater for four years now, and they ve followed me through basically every address I ve stayed! The ALWAYS find your place without a problem, even if it s complex on campus. This is my GO-TO always, it s just an overall amazing experience! Once I ordered and they were out of my drink, the driver literally drove to a Wal-Mart to fulfill an order. I told the man to keep it, but he went out of his way to make sure it got to me. I cannot thank this dominos enough for the countless times they ve pulled though.

★★★★★
April 9, 2022

This dominos always gets my order correct and is always quick! Great pizza!

April 9, 2022

This is by far the worst pizza I have ever had from Dominos...it was far too done, and so very very dry...there wasnt hardy any sauce or cheese on it at all. I wont be ordering from there again anytime soon...

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

Delicious

Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

We love dominoes but this was TERRIBLE. ugh.

April 9, 2022

You would think after paying $4 for EXTRA ranch, they would of at least given me the original 1 they give with every order. But nope. No idea how their average rating is as high as it is. Not the first problem, it s something every time

★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

Ordered 2 pizzas and took forever to get my order

★★★★★
April 9, 2022

It is a terrific place and every one was great the people working there were very helpful Thank.you

★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

Fair !! Pizza.

★★★★★
April 9, 2022

Theyre always efficient! good pizza too :)

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

Always great

★★
April 9, 2022

For the third time my pizza had bacon while I ordered only chicken with some veggies. Really frustrated how inconsiderate people can be. I didn t even bother to ask refund this time.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

I LOVE the drive through pick up window. Good pizza & good prices

April 9, 2022

It wasnt fresh and stail

Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

Delivery takes forever, I ended up cancelled the order after more than 2 hours of waiting... The pizza was taken by the delivery driver for almost an hour so it must be real cold if it gets here...

April 9, 2022

My food was burned.

April 9, 2022

Very dry very little sauce and even less cheese. I order pepperoni hand tossed its the same every time it look feels and tastes old every single time. I sincerely feel they are cooking them ahead of time at lunch.. I ordered at exactly when they opened the pizza came quickly and still the cheese was hard when I got it. As someone who has a lifetime in food service and works as executive sous chef I can tell how old food is by looking it They had good pizza up until around May 2020 ever since the approximately 10 orders I have made have been well below subpar.. The drivers consistently get lost. They have delivered to the wrong apt they have driven back to the restaurant and they have sent me out a 90 minute old pizza that I told them not to send cause I dont want old dry pizza. This is a management or ownership problem I would stay away. Pony up the extra cash and get hideaway its a 1000x times better then the Stillwater Dominoes.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

Always slams love the food here

★★★★★
April 9, 2022

Very please with the two pizzas I bought. Thanks to miss Tracy they got to me quick and were still warm.

★★
April 9, 2022

I used to be a manger at domino s. This facility does not know how to properly make their pizzas. The crust is too thick and uneven, and the base of the dough is spread way too thin. Every single pizza dough is spread thin and unevenly. There s supposed to be a rise in the hand tossed pizza, and this facility never has that. Their large pizzas done out as the size of mediums, and the overall quality is poor. I ve never had pizza at another domino s that is this poorly made. Save your money and spend it on a pizza facility that understands joe to craft their pizzas.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2022

Wish I took pictures, it looked like the commercials. Was really tasty, ready in like 15 and even my picky eater enjoyed it.

April 9, 2021

First time ordering from Dominos...I wont order again.... I got a sandwich...and it was basically bread....my boyfriend got the chicken Alfredo...and the stuff was burnt on the inside.... wont be oderiord from them again...

★★★★★
April 9, 2021

Thanks for the free pizza. It was delicious!

Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

I have called four times in a row and I ve got put on hold four times in a row with a span of 30 minutes and I get hung up on every time

Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

Twice. Twice I have ordered from this location and recieved poor service. Why bother offer contactless curbside if youre just going to ignore it? We were passed by 4 employees who didnt even say anything. Will NOT be returning. Edit: The pizza was horribly uneven, and the wings barely had any sauce. Awful.

★★★★★
April 9, 2021

Amazing pizza! The crust is to die for!

★★★★★
April 9, 2021

Always on Time, very reasonable prices, Absolutely Amazing Food, and with points they give you FREE food!!!!

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

Had to wait for are pizzas

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

Pizza was good

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

Great pizza & salads

★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

I just ordered some pizza, and the women on the phone was not professional and was rude !!!! Smh

April 9, 2021

The awkward moment when you pay extra for DOUBLE Alfredo sauce, but it has the same amount as single Alfredo. I have been ordering the same pizza for 4 years (large thin, double Alfredo double spinach), but just recently you changed the amount of Alfredo sauce you put on your pizza. I asked them to remake the pizzas, but you said that you are unable to do so due to the current pandemic

★★★★★
April 9, 2021

Very inexpensive for a lg. pizza, anywhere in Stillwater, and was pleased with the quality of it.

★★★★
April 9, 2021

They always delivery our food on time and sometimes before the time. Except with our order this time before last but in a collage town only one late delivery is great to me!!! Their food is always good and we prefer it over the other chain pizza places. I do not review often but they have impressed me. Only reason it wasn t a 5 star review is because the late delivery I mentioned above.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

They forgot to make one of my pizzas and forgot to put sauce on my wings. But thats all minor. They have good pizza

★★★★★
April 9, 2021

On time at the window or at my door , best pizza in town ...

April 9, 2021

I ordered few hours ago online for my husband to pick up a Brooklyn baked Cali Chicken speciality pizza and instead he was served a thin crust pizza,this is the second time

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

Oh my sweet baby jesus

★★★★★
April 9, 2021

Great, thank you

April 9, 2021

the management is awful. I order a pizza and after 24 min i noticed that they didnt take the order!!! very disappointing!

★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

Good affordable food

Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

I ordered a LARGE CHEESE PIZZA at 6:14, it s now 6:50 and I just got it. Wasn t made when I arrived at my pick up time. Sat at the window for an additional 8 min, several workers made eye contact with me and didn t come to the window. When I got my pizza I asked for marinara sauce and they said well we charge for it and I was like well I waited here an extra 30 min because y all didn t make my pizza and the response was yeah I was gonna say, I ll just give it to you for free no. You weren t. Bad service.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

Yummy

Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

They routinely forget to put the sauce on their sandwiches. Then they act like youre trying to rip them off by asking for sauce. I can understand forgetting it sometimes. But its almost every time. How is it a mango habanero sandwich of theres no mango habanero sauce on it? Its not, its just a toasted chicken sandwich and thats not what I order. Very poor customer service and no attention to detail at this location

★★
April 9, 2021

Skimpy on the toppings and the large isnt very large with six slices giving the mirage of a large pizza.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

Hot fresh and super fast!

★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

Everytime I go here I get great pizza from friendly staff. My son, who can be hard to please, really enjoys the pizza he gets there. Both of my kids, really, enjoy the pizza they get here. One of the things they enjoy is the stuffed cheese bread or garlic knots.

April 9, 2021

My food was raw :( I tried to call and after 7 minutes of ringing no answer... guess that is 20 dollars down the drain!

★★
April 9, 2021

They made us the wrong pizza and when we told them they said there was nothing that they could do about it :(

April 9, 2021

Pizza was cold and they got our order wrong.

★★★★★
April 9, 2021

I love Dominos Pizza!

★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

I noticed that this location is locally owned and they did NOT enforce COVID mandates.

April 9, 2021

They girl who answered the call when I wanted to order pizza for delivery was rude ,impolite and impatient she just said I m putting you on hold while I was in the busy telling her what I wanted on my pizza ,training to this employee would be helpful for the business

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2021

The best there is dont eat any other place.

April 9, 2021

Had to drive across town twice in the rain cause I was given the wrong pizza. Then to top it off the guy at the window was super rude and our pizza was cold. Im completely dissatisfied and will never be coming back.

April 9, 2021

Ordered 3 pizzas, two thin crust and one pan crust. Also ordered 2 10pc wings. One dry, one buffalo sauce. We got 3 thin crust pizzas and 2 10pc wings dry

★★★★★
April 9, 2020

The food is so good and always prepared perfectly. Also the GM Cayla is pretty cool and seems like a good person.

★★★★★
April 9, 2020

This Dominos always has great deals, especially for college kids! The management is exceptional and spends quality time making things right!

★★★★★
April 9, 2020

The food is always delicious and the service is fast. The staff are friendly and helpful. Angel always helps me decide what to order when I m unsure. Such a sweet gal. Keep up the great work guys!

★★★★★
April 9, 2020

Love the carryout deals and new recipe is for real. Good service every time I go.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2020

Their cheese bread is great.

★★★★★
April 9, 2020

This is the only place i wanna eat pizza for the rest of my life

★★★★★
April 9, 2020

Live next door and order from here a bunch. Pretty good consistent service and friendly staff

★★★★★
April 9, 2020

This pizza cured me, the staff is awesome, and the coupons are off the chain. Much love to the drivers

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2020

The thin crust pizza is pretty good here. You can pick up from the window also

★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2020

Theyre crust is hands down the best. Love the pizza, love the specials too, the 5.99 mediums! The only thing is they make you buy peppers and cheese

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 9, 2020

Really really good

April 9, 2020

The most horrible service Ive ever had, Ive waited over an hour an 30 for my order so I call and they tell me Ive never placed an order with them. the manager who go on the phone was rude and hung up on me. I love dominos but I will never order from this place again. Very rude service will not recommend to anyone...

★★★★★
April 9, 2020

Ive ordered right around 49 or 50 different times from this Dominos and theyve NEVER got my order wrong. Plus I have 6 free pizzas just waiting to be redeemed in my account so this Dominos gets a 5 out of 5

★★
April 9, 2020

Pretty nasty for a dominos

★★★★★
April 9, 2020

I have had troubles with your online ordering of specialty pizzas a number of time, but this time, smooth as silk.