Stoltzfus Auto Care Center in Warsaw

5478 US-20A, Warsaw, NY 14569, United States

★★★★★
(56 reviews)
Specialties: Auto repair shop

About

Stoltzfus Auto Care Center LLC. (formerly Barny’s Auto Care), is a licensed NYS Repair and Inspection facility. We specialize in mechanical repairs and servicing of foreign and domestic vehicles, and diagnosis of your electrical concerns. Thanks for checking us out! We look forward to serving you!

Website
stoltzfusautocarecenter.com
Address
5478 US-20A, Warsaw, NY 14569, United States
Plus Code
PVWH+CP Warsaw, New York, USA
Time Zone
America/New_York

Business Hours

Sunday
Closed
Monday
8 am–5 pm
Tuesday
8 am–5 pm
Wednesday
8 am–5 pm
Thursday
8 am–5 pm
Friday
8 am–5 pm
Saturday
Closed

Services

Service options
On-site services
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park Wheelchair-accessible entrance Assistive hearing loop Wheelchair-accessible seating
Offerings
Oil change
Amenities
Mechanic Toilet
Planning
Appointments recommended
Payments
Credit cards Debit cards NFC mobile payments Credit cards

Reviews

4.9
★★★★★
56 reviews

Most Mentioned

vehicle (8) prices (5) trip (4) inspection (3) area (3) honest (3) mini cooper (2) communication (2) diagnosed (2) oil (2)
5 stars
54
4 stars
1
3 stars
1
2 stars
0
1 stars
0
★★★★★
January 23, 2025

Amazing experience! Don’t go anywhere else. We were well taken care of and they had my car fixed very quickly.

★★★★★
January 22, 2025

Great service and friendly techs. Best repair shop in the area, and they know their stuff. Highly recommend, and we have been taking all of our cars there for 3 years as of the date of this post.

★★★★★
January 17, 2025

We recently had our vehicle in for repairs. Working with Brian and Aaron was a great experience. They take the time to go over what your vehicle needs and provide you with a detailed repair plan with photographs. Excellent communication and a great overall experience.

★★★★★
October 30, 2024

It is so nice to have an auto care center so close. When a need work done I drive up they bring me home then pick me up when the work is done. I have had them change the oil, replace the brakes and install 4 new tires. All at very reasonable prices

★★★★★
October 7, 2024

The BEST customer service and communication--not just of any garage, but of any business I've ever dealt with. Brian and his crew have done an amazing job with fixing my car, communicating about the necessary fixes, and about what things can wait. I took my car to a different local oil change place for an inspection and they told me I needed new tires and brakes. Turned out neither were true. Brian figured out what actually had to be done and took care of it. I highly recommend Stoltzfus!

★★★★★
September 6, 2024

We were visiting the area and experienced vehicle problems. Worrying that we might be stranded we ended up at Stoltzfus Auto Centre where we met Shawn. He immediately took care of us, diagnosed the problem and had us back on our way within an hour. He did great work and the cost was reasonable. Very happy with both the work and customer service. Thanks Shawn.

★★★★★
August 14, 2024

The young guy with black hair was super nice to us and offered help when it was needed!! They seem to have a clean station and answered all the questions I asked no matter how small. Don't go annoying them with too much questions tho!! They seemed to be popular with the locals too because we went there with the recommendation of the owner of Glosser’s ice cream and farmers market! They have great produce there!

★★★★★
November 2, 2023

This place is amazing! The people are so nice and go above and beyond for helping out in any situation. I was on the way to Virginia from Buffalo and my thermostat housing popped in my car and I had to get towed back to the shop. They made sure that I got back on the road the very next morning!

Review photo
★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
December 19, 2024

Great local friendly service. Knowledgeable Mini Cooper and BMW service and repair for our cars.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
October 19, 2024

Great

★★★★★
September 19, 2024

Shawn and Aaron were awesome! They didnt try to over diagnose or over charge me. They fixed me up and had me on my way in an hour with no further issues the rest of my travels.

★★★★★
August 19, 2024

These guys are great! Fixed my truck in a timely manner and did great work.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
July 19, 2024

Brian saved the day for us! Thank you so much for your kindness and fast repair. We made it to our destination, and I think we will be ok to make it back to !

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
July 19, 2024

Our vehicle was beyond repair. Sean and Brian were patient with us while we made the inevitable decision to scrap it. They helped us find someone who would take it away and give us $250!

★★★★★
May 19, 2024

Really good customer service and work!!!! Brian (the owner) is very honest and fair

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
April 19, 2024

These guys repaired our unique vehicle situation in a timely manner and did very professional work. I highly recommend!

★★★★★
March 19, 2024

They were awesome! We ran over a bungee cord on the highway that slashed our tire and found them on internet. The young man who helped us was great. He found us a good used tire at a great price and put it on quickly. Five stars for sure!

★★★★★
March 19, 2024

Brian, thoroughly inspected my car and not only addressed the issues I mentioned but also went above and beyond to ensure that my vehicle received the necessary care. His expertise and attention to detail were truly impressive. Professional and great service! Thank you!

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
March 19, 2024

Stoltzfus is great!!! We take both our vehicles there for service. Their customer service is second to none! One time, I had an issue with my vehicle that of course, wouldnt present itself while there. Brian called me a few days later to see if the car was still doing okay because he was concerned that they werent able to find the issue. Ive never experienced that kind of customer service and really appreciated it! I highly recommend them to everyone in need of auto care.

★★★★★
March 19, 2024

Really nice people! Thanks for your help

★★★★★
March 19, 2024

This business is one of most professional shops Ive ever been to.I was told step by step what would be done.And everyone was very knowledgeable and went out of their way to answer my questions.I would give them 10 stars if possible.Thank You Brian and Shaun, I will continue to use your services.

★★★★★
March 19, 2024

This establishment is very accommodating and theral. If you want to work with someone honest give Brian or one of his guys a call!

★★★★★
March 19, 2024

Great foreign car service for our Mini Cooper S and BMW. At reasonable cost. It is a locally owned business.

★★★★★
March 19, 2023

Outstanding little shop. Half the shops I call are afraid to work on my Volkswagen. Not Stolzfus. A very friendly and honest shop who can work on anything and do it right.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
March 19, 2023

We take both of our vehicles there for our automotive needs (transmission, brake lines, inspection etc). Fast, efficient service and great/fair prices that cant be beat!

★★★★★
March 19, 2023

Brian at Stoltzfus was absolutely incredible. I was two hours from home and still an hour away from a hockey tournament my kids and I were traveling to. He got us right in, took great care of us, and had us back on our way in no time so we didn t miss the game. He was polite and respectful to myself and my children! Highly recommend !

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
March 19, 2023

Needed a new tire, I thought. But they were able to fix it and encouraged me I had a good 80% tread left! Was pretty thankful for the honesty and advice. Very professional, helpful, and kind. Thank you for making this trip more enjoyable through a difficult time.

★★★★★
March 19, 2023

We were incredibly pleased with the service and kindness shown by Brian. We were driving down to Florida from Canada when we started to experience transmission issues while passing Stoltzfus Auto Center. Although the shop was booked solid and very busy, Brian dropped everything to help diagnose our problem and arrange for a transmission shop in another town to get us in the same day. Recognizing that we were stranded, being from out of town, Brian also volunteered to personally drive us to a hotel as well as to the town our vehicle was being towed to the following day. He definitely went above and beyond for us and his kindness didnt go unappreciated. Furthermore, he even followed up with us to make sure we were able to get our vehicle fixed and back on the road to Florida. Thank you again Brian !!

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
March 19, 2022

They are the best customer service people Ive run across in a long time. Unfailingly polite and respectful. And they fix things right. Couldnt be happier.

★★★★★
March 19, 2022

Honest and reliable

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
March 19, 2022

I brought my car in for an inspection and had a few things that needed attention. They explained what needed immediate repair and what could wait. I appreciate the attention to detail and honesty that I found at Stoltzfuss.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
March 19, 2022

Very friendly, and knowledgeable staff... quick service! Definitely recommend this place. I came from Ohio with a bulged tire, and they got me in and out with a new tire within 30 minutes.

★★★★★
March 19, 2022

I honestly did not get any repair work done here, but if I am ever in the area and need an urgent repair will 100% come here - my family (5 month old baby, wife and two dogs) took our new travel trailer out and on the way home my GPS took me the worst possible way, I ended up low on gas and at the bridge with a low clearance and right before the bridge was this auto shop, I was not fully sure if I could clear the bridge and to get back to the thruway would have been 30 minutes the opposite direction, we pulled in and the guys here were the most genuine and nice people I could have asked for in the situation I was in, they let me drop my 30 foot trailer there so I could go get gas, and with all the stress of everything they let me leave it there a few hours while I drove home to drop my family off so I could go back and get it home myself with out the worry of having everyone else in the car. I honestly cannot say thank you enough, I have no doubt these people are honest and treat people fairly with how kind they were to me when I was not even buying any services from them. Thank you again!!

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
March 19, 2022

Great service, very friendly and explains things in a way you can understand what they are talking about

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
March 19, 2022

The only place I go to have my car worked on. Its a convenient location only a few miles from my house, with fast, friendly service and reasonable prices.

★★★★★
March 19, 2021

Very knowledgable crew with thorough attention to detail! Russ explained their recommendations to me clearly and got the work done in a timely fashion. I will return Barneys.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
March 19, 2021

Very friendly staff who will tell you what you need fixed and not try to sell you on things that you don t need. Service was quick and done right. Would definitely recommend this place for auto service.

★★★★★
March 19, 2021

Great service

★★★★★
March 19, 2020

Always been able to solve my problem and far rates.

★★★★★
March 19, 2020

Russ has always treated me right.

★★★★
Verified Reviewer
March 19, 2020

Good service.

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
March 19, 2019

ALWAYS A++++ SERVICE

★★★★★
Verified Reviewer
March 19, 2018

Russ and the staff at Barneys are great. They will fix issue correctly and dont take short cuts. This is by far the best shop with out driving an hour away. From general maintenance to diagnostics they are the experts. Keep up the great work everyone!!!!